
Property tax under the new law was levied for the first time on 1 January 2025. Prior to this, all properties in Germany had to be revalued, which involved a great deal of effort and the direct participation of all property owners. The manner of implementation sparked heated controversy. The Federal Finance Court has now issued its ruling.
Property tax (GrSt) is a tax on real estate ownership in Germany. It is payable by the owner and can be passed on to tenants. Property tax is a significant source of revenue for local authorities. Due to considerable concerns about the new procedure, lawsuits are currently pending in various courts.
In the property tax proceedings, the Federal Finance Court (BFH) has fully confirmed the federal model and dismissed the lawsuits. This means that the controversial valuation rules and the notices issued on their basis remain legally valid for the time being, as announced by Haus & Grund Deutschland and the Taxpayers' Association of Germany (BdSt). Both associations subsequently announced that they would jointly support a constitutional complaint to the Federal Constitutional Court.
"The new property tax has become more complex, more expensive and more unfair for many citizens. We will therefore push ahead with the constitutional review of the property tax in Karlsruhe," announced Kai Warnecke, President of Haus & Grund Deutschland. BdSt President Reiner Holznagel emphasised: "Many taxpayers see the reform as an XXL burden. If the Federal Finance Court (BFH) does not set any limits here, the Federal Constitutional Court should examine whether the federal model is compatible with the principle of equality. That is why we will jointly file a constitutional complaint."
The associations point to significant additional burdens in numerous cities and municipalities, even though the reform had been announced as politically revenue-neutral. At the same time, they criticise the heavy reliance on standard land values and flat-rate net cold rents, which make properties in sought-after locations in particular massively more expensive.
Photo: © Simon, Pixabay